Marshall Memo 1138
A Weekly Round-up of Important Ideas and Research in K-12 Education
May 18, 2026
1. Twelve ways principals can build collective efficacy
2. Angela Duckworth on willpower, cellphones, and AI
3. Can students learn instructional content from TikTok and YouTube?
4. Using an automated scoring program with middle-school writing
5. Hidden linguistic difficulties in math word problems
6. Key factors that affect beginning readers
7. Teen novels about surviving emotional trauma
8. Troubling data on high-school sophomores
“Did students learn what we just taught, and what are we doing right now if they did not?”
Terry Grier in “Schools Are Investing in the Wrong Sorts of Assessment. How to Get It
Right” in Education Week, May 12, 2026
“AI is not coming for education someday. It is already here, and the schools that keep pretending otherwise are not protecting students. They are preparing them for a world that no longer exists.”
Stefan Bauschard in “Education Disrupted: Teaching and Learning in an AI World”,
May 11, 2026
“Many think it’s not good for them and many worry it’s making them lazy and stupid.”
Angela Duckworth on artificial intelligence (see item #2)
“Do it well or not at all.”
Joshua Wilson et al. on an automated writing scoring program (see item #4)
Peijuan Cao and Ling Hao (see item #5)
In their 2025 book, Collective Impact, Jenni Donohoo and Glenn Forbes describe how school leaders can increase teacher efficacy, one of the most important ingredients in highly effective schools. Collective efficacy is educators’ belief that they, as a group, can make a positive difference to student achievement. Studies show that when a faculty has this belief, its members put in more effort, think more strategically, and demonstrate greater commitment. It’s at the top of John Hattie’s list of key factors in high academic and SEL achievement.
Donohoo and Forbes name twelve “enemies” that frequently undermine teacher efficacy and organize their book around ways school leaders can counteract each one:
• Blaming poverty, parents, and students’ lack of effort – Pinning low student achievement on factors outside teachers’ control undermines their motivation to do better. The antidote: highlighting where teachers are succeeding and connecting specific practices to impact on student learning. Rather than saying, “Good job!” to a teacher, a principal might say, “I saw you provide scaffolding to your struggling students on the spot. That’s a skill that many teachers take a long time to develop. Did you notice how effective it was? That support meant they could participate and reach the lesson’s objectives.”
• The magnitude of the task – When improving student achievement seems too daunting, teacher efficacy falters. The antidote: reframe the challenge in terms of small, specific actions teachers and teacher teams can take with available resources within a finite amount of time – for example, a one-month plan for fifth graders to work on one skill in their essay writing.
• Fragmentation – A Christmas tree of initiatives in a school undermines focused collaboration and fosters cynicism (This too shall pass). The antidote: find out which 20 percent of teacher actions are producing 80 percent of the results (the Pareto Principle) and focus the school on those super-productive practices, de-emphasizing those that are adding less value.
• Ambiguity on school goals – If staff members don’t have a clear sense of what their school’s major priorities and initiatives are, there’s going to be less productive collaboration. If there’s uncertainty about people’s roles and the definition of practices – for example, student-led versus student-centered – collective efficacy will suffer. The antidote: ensure that staff members have a shared understanding and consensus on key ideas and practices and reinforce those by encouraging colleagues to recognize and appreciate classroom successes in those areas.
• Uncertainty about what administrators are thinking – For example, The assistant principal didn’t give me eye contact – is she mad because I voiced concerns about the schedule? The antidote: communicate openly and clearly, minimize ambiguity, and check in on whether what you are saying and doing are received as intended.
• Hierarchical thinking – When school leaders wield their authority in a controlling, top-down manner, teachers work with a fearful attitude, don’t take risks, close their classroom doors, and avoid collaboration. The antidote: distribute leadership, delegate tasks, encourage mentorships, hold teacher-led professional development, empower teams to experiment with new instructional initiatives, and provide discretionary funds for promising projects. It’s also important for leaders to know what individuals are good at and encourage them to play to those strengths.
• A compliance mentality – When teachers feel they’re being managed to follow top-down policies, they go through the motions – or silently undermine mandates. The antidote: get out of compliance mode and find ways to persuade teachers to use best practices because they work. If there are concerns about a program, invite teachers to articulate their reasons and try variations, measuring the impact on students who weren’t doing well.
• Teacher isolation – Educators may feel cut off from their colleagues because of their own insecurities, the schedule (no common meeting times), or being a “lonely singleton” (the only music teacher in a school). Isolated teachers learn less from their colleagues, and their colleagues learn less from them, limiting the spread of good ideas. The antidote: fix the schedule so there are common planning times at least once a week and orchestrate tasks that foster interdependence – for example, drafting and giving common assessments, planning grade-wide projects, visiting each other’s classrooms, and shadowing a student for a day – followed by sharing insights.
• Avoiding collaboration – Teachers may not contribute ideas and energy to their grade-level or department team because they worry their methods might be questioned or aren’t comfortable with interpersonal conflict. This might take the form of skipping team meetings, contributing only the bare minimum, or not addressing problems that can only be solved through collaboration. The antidote: flip the dynamic in unproductive team meetings by emphasizing strengths and attributing positive student results to those actions. Spotlight specific actions, encourage teachers to journal about positive learning moments, and draw on your own interpersonal and pedagogical strengths.
• Negativity – Sour attitudes, pessimism, and defeatism can spread like a virus within a school, blocking positive emotions and a can-do attitude. The antidote: find small accomplishments and celebrate them, reinforcing optimism that specific practices make a difference. A principal might open a staff meeting by describing a delightful moment in a classroom or orchestrating recognition circles where colleagues appreciate each other in specific ways.
• Judgmental comments – When teachers hear comments like Her ideas are always unrealistic or He’s impossible to work with, they stop sharing opinions, don’t speak up in meetings, and refrain from sharing ideas with their team. The antidote: model norms of collaboration that foster psychological safety so teachers feel protected from being judged. Advocate for being curious about other viewpoints, holding off on criticism, and responding productively to ideas that might seem off base.
• Invidious comparisons – Humans tend to compare themselves unfavorably with others, and a competitive environment in a school can bring this out, fostering self-doubt and withdrawal from collective effort. The antidote: downplay competition among teachers and don’t publicly compare teachers or teacher teams. Instead, compare classroom practices and results to mastery goals and focus on specific practices (like wait-time and checking for understanding) and student work (like exit tickets and interim assessments) that are within teachers’ span of control.
Collective Impact by Jenni Donohoo and Glenn Forbes (Solution Tree, 2025); this summary draws on Jenn David-Lang’s more-comprehensive précis in this month’s The Main Idea, with her permission.
In this article in Edutopia, Andrew Boryga interviews grit guru Angela Duckworth (University of Pennsylvania). Some excerpts:
Willpower, on its own, isn’t the most effective way to avoid doing something undesirable (like taking a second helping of dessert), says Duckworth. She’s found that a better approach is situational agency – deliberately structuring one’s environment to make desirable choices more likely. Examples: turning off the cellphone and putting it out of reach during study time; not having junk food readily available; writing down specific goals and putting them on a sticky note where you’ll see them every day.
In a recent study Duckworth conducted, teachers reported that about one-third of students are using laptops in class for non-academic activities. “I look at those numbers and I see the next frontier for technology policies in schools,” she says: limiting students’ access to the temptation of watching YouTube videos or texting during instructional time.
Many students are using AI on a daily basis, but are deeply ambivalent about it. “Many think it’s not good for them,” says Duckworth, “and many worry it’s making them lazy and stupid.” The same principles apply here, she believes – structuring the environment to maximize the positive aspects of AI and limiting those that are not helpful.
In this article in The Learning Dispatch, Carl Hendrick (Academica University, Amsterdam) describes the way many teenagers are watching instructional videos (often on a phone propped up against their textbook):
In this article in American Educational Research Journal, Joshua Wilson (University of Delaware) and eight co-authors report on their study of middle-school teachers in three school districts (labeled District A, B, and C) using an automated scoring system (MI Write) to give seventh and eighth graders immediate feedback on their writing. The researchers assessed whether having 1,260 students use the system for a year would improve their argumentative writing, self- efficacy, enjoyment of writing, and beliefs in the recursive nature of writing – comparing them with a control group of 1,227 students who did not use MI Write.
The researchers focused on argumentative writing because they believe it is especially important to critical thinking, evidence-based reasoning, and the ability to communicate and justify a well-organized position – skills recognized as essential to college success.
Wilson et al. say research has identified characteristics of effective writing instruction, including a process approach, pre-writing, strategy instruction, feedback, and peer assistance. Despite the importance of writing and a solid knowledge base, “writing receives minimal instructional time,” say the authors, “teachers often feel underprepared to teach and assess writing,” and students get infrequent feedback on their efforts – on average once a month.
The result of the neglect of writing in most U.S. schools: fewer than one quarter of eighth graders write proficiently, with argumentative writing showing deficits in factual accuracy, persuasiveness, alternative perspectives, counterarguments, and correct grammar and mechanics. Proficiency gaps are more pronounced among students of color and those from low-income communities, with only 10-13 percent of those students meeting standards.
Wilson and his co-authors hoped that using an AI-based program that gave students immediate feedback on their writing drafts would bring about improvements. The MI Write system followed the process writing approach and gave students quick feedback on each stage, including planning, drafting, reviewing, editing their spelling and grammar, revising, and publishing. Immediate feedback was a big improvement on what teachers could manage with a caseload of over 100 students, and allowed teachers to focus more on higher-level writing skills such as generating ideas – areas often neglected when teachers have to hand-correct so many papers.
What did the researchers find? There were stark differences among the three districts in how well MI Write was implemented. District A had limited fidelity and the least favorable teacher perceptions of the program. District B reported better perceptions but had poor fidelity because teachers were focused on implementing another curriculum. District C implemented the program more thoroughly in terms of the number of prompts to which students responded, the number of drafts per essay, the number that were revised two or more times, and teachers had favorable reactions to the program.
At the end of the study, researchers arranged for human scoring of students’ writing samples, and the overall results closely tracked how well the program was implemented. District A showed no impact on outcomes, District B had a negative impact on two measures of student writing, and District C had positive results across the board, including impact on students’ writing quality.
The researchers’ main takeaway: implementing an automated writing program is challenging and depends heavily on local context. Although teachers in all three districts received training, monthly coaching, and on-demand technical support, and had a positive reaction to MI Write, Districts A and B implemented the system – and students used it – far less frequently than intended (contributing to this were disruptions during the 2021-22 school year due to Covid-19). Part of the problem in Districts A and B was also that teachers didn’t reorganize the schedule to give more time to writing.
It’s clear that by itself, this kind of automated writing feedback program will not move the needle on student outcomes and other factors; broader changes in scheduling and emphasis on writing are needed. Given the issues they encountered in District A and B, the researchers’ suggestion on implementing programs like MI Write: Do it well or not at all.
“Impact of Automated Writing Evaluation on Middle-School Students’ Writing Outcomes” by Joshua Wilson, Corey Palermo, Matthew Myers, Tania Cruz Cordero, Halley Eacker, Andrew Potter, Jessica Coles, Henry May, and Fan Zhang in American Educational Research Journal, February 2026 (Vol. 63, #1, pp. 72-108); Wilson can be reached at [email protected].
In this Journal of Adolescent and Adult Literacy article, Peijuan Cao (Appalachian State University) and Ling Hao (Illinois State University) say that solving math word problems asks students to navigate not only mathematical reasoning but also linguistic complexity. Here’s an example of a problem that attempts to engage students by describing a real-world situation but contains a challenge for some students:
Cao and Hao analyzed dozens of ninth-grade math word problems and developed a codebook to help teachers and students anticipate and unpack specific linguistic features, including the following:
In this article in Reading Research Quarterly, Andrea Salins (Australian Catholic University) and five co-authors explore the links between first and second graders’ engagement with reading, their reading fluency, anxiety about learning to read, parents’ involvement, and reading proficiency. Some conclusions:
“Re-examining the Survival Fiction Genre” by Jen Spisak in Knowledge Quest, March/April 2026 (Vol. 54, #4, pp. 42-45); Spisak can be reached at [email protected].
In this Kappan article on conditions in U.S. high schools, Dustin Hornbeck (University of Memphis) quotes findings from a troubling 2025 Brookings study of 10th graders:
© Copyright 2026 Marshall Memo LLC – AI is not used to create this publication.
You have permission to share summaries with colleagues for educational purposes, being sure to include the author/publication citation and mention that it’s a Marshall Memo summary.
About the Marshall Memo
Mission and focus:
This weekly memo is designed to keep principals, teachers, superintendents, and other educators very well-informed on current research and effective practices in K-12 education. Kim Marshall, drawing on 54 years’ experience as a teacher, principal, central office administrator, writer, and consultant lightens the load of busy educators by serving as their “designated reader.”
To produce the Marshall Memo, Kim subscribes to 60 carefully-chosen publications (see list to the right), sifts through more than a hundred articles each week, and selects 5-10 that have the greatest potential to improve teaching, leadership, and learning. He then writes a brief summary of each article, pulls out several striking quotes, provides e-links to full articles when available, and e-mails the Memo to subscribers early Tuesday (there are 50 issues a year). Every week there’s a podcast and HTML version. Artificial intelligence is not used.
Individual subscriptions are $50 for a year. Rates decline steeply for multiple readers within the same organization. See the website for these rates and how to pay by check, credit card, or purchase order.
Website:
If you go to http://www.marshallmemo.com you will find detailed information on:
• How to subscribe or renew
• A detailed rationale for the Marshall Memo
• Article selection criteria
• Publications (with a count of articles from each)
• Topics (with a count of articles from each)
• Headlines for all issues
• Reader opinions
• About Kim Marshall (including links to articles)
• A free sample issue
Subscribers have access to the Members’ Area of the website, which has:
• The current issue (in Word or PDF)
• All back issues (Word and PDF) and podcasts
• An easily searchable archive of all articles so far
• The “classic” articles from all 20 years
Core list of publications covered
Those read this week are underlined.
All Things PLC
American Educational Research Journal
American Educator
American Journal of Education
AMLE Magazine
ASCA School Counselor
ASCD SmartBrief
Cult of Pedagogy
District Management Journal
Ed Magazine
Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis
Educational Horizons
Educational Leadership
Elementary School Journal
English Journal
Exceptional Children
Harvard Business Review
Harvard Educational Review
Independent School
Journal of Adolescent and Adult Literacy
Journal of Education for Students Placed At Risk (JESPAR)
Kappa Delta Pi Record
Kappan (Phi Delta Kappan)
Knowledge Quest
Language Arts
Language Magazine
Learning for Justice (formerly Teaching Tolerance)
Literacy Today (formerly Reading Today)
Mathematics Teacher: Learning & Teaching PK-12
Middle School Journal
Peabody Journal of Education
Principal
Principal Leadership
Psychology Today
Reading Research Quarterly
Rethinking Schools
Review of Educational Research
School Administrator
School Library Journal
Social Education
Social Studies and the Young Learner
Teaching Exceptional Children
The Atlantic
The Chronicle of Higher Education
The Journal of the Learning Sciences
The Language Educator
The Learning Professional (formerly Journal of Staff Development)
The Reading Teacher
Theory Into Practice
Time
Urban Education