Marshall Memo 1136
A Weekly Round-up of Important Ideas and Research in K-12 Education
May 4, 2026
1. Five principles of learning and how they can be put to work in schools
2. Zaretta Hammond on countering the effects of “cognitive redlining”
3. Challenges when successful practices are taken to scale
4. Workplace accommodations for neurodivergent adults
5. Jennifer Gonzalez on lesson plans that stand the test of time
“One cannot hope to implement change without persuading people that it is necessary.”
M-J Mercanti-Anthony in “How School Leaders Can Introduce the Science of
Learning” in The Learning Professional, April 2026 (Vol. 47, #2, pp. 28-31)
“Being anti-racist is not enough to reverse the effects of cognitive neglect. Too often, we think if we just affirm students’ cultural identities, reduce microaggressions, or make the content relevant to students’ racial and linguistic identity, they will engage and learn.”
Zaretta Hammond (see item #2)
“When 20 percent of Harvard and Brown students and 36 percent of Stanford’s are eligible for accommodations, even as just 3-4 percent of students in community colleges are, we have a crisis of trust in testing, fairness, and equity. Designed to be rare, accommodations now seem to be given out like candy, especially to those who know how to press for them – mostly the wealthy. Where are the defenders of academic standards, equality of opportunity, and valid assessments?”
Miriam Kurtzig Freedman in “Accommodations Are a Concern, But Don’t Blame
Parents” in Education Gadfly, April 30, 2026
“Rigor, rightly understood, means having high standards coupled with assessments that give true results… Students need support in reaching the standards and navigating the assessments. You can’t just drop a rope from the ceiling and tell a student to climb it… Rigor without humanity is just performative toughness.”
Robert Talbert in “Six Things I Think I Think About Rigor” in Grading for Growth,
April 27, 2026
“Oral history can allow us to broaden our viewpoint and see how our stories interweave with the story of our neighborhood, our town, our country. That can give people a sense of their place in American history. When we read about things in textbooks, they may seem irrelevant, but when we think about how they directly connect to our families, they become more compelling.”
Rachel Seidman in “The Stories That Shape Us” in Psychology Today, May/June 2026
“The manosphere thrives by exploiting the need for boys and young men to belong, a developmental vulnerability schools know well. It offers boys a seductive bargain: ‘If you feel rejected, ashamed, confused, lonely, or powerless, do not reflect, connect, or ask for help. Instead, dominate and blame women, mock weakness, never apologize, and never need anyone.’ That is not strength. It is emotional illiteracy dressed up as power… To make safer, healthier, more-humane school communities, leaders must ensure their buildings and the people who work in them foster an environment that equips boys with emotional intelligence and teaches them to respect boundaries, challenge misogyny and entitlement, and build healthy relationships rooted in compassion, accountability, and real connection.”
Mark Brackett in “A School Leader’s Guide for Countering the Manosphere” in
Education Week, April 29, 2026
In this article in The Learning Professional, Jim Heal and Margaret Lee (Learning Science Partners) say that a lot of K-12 professional development is “outwardly attractive and exciting at first glance, but ultimately superficial and short-lived.” To improve PD for adults (and learning for students), Heal and Lee ask a basic question: How does learning happen, and how should we teach as a result? Drawing on cognitive science research, they suggest that teachers, instructional coaches, principals, and district leaders apply these key ideas:
• Retrieval practice – Teachers give quizzes and tests to assess what students have learned, but many don’t realize that when students fetch information from their brain, that memory is strengthened. “Retrieval is not a test of learning,” say Heal and Lee. “It is learning. When teachers understand retrieval first as a principle of the mind beforeconsidering it as a practical strategy, they can transform its use in the classroom beyond simple testing to a mechanism that supports student learning.” Professional development should convey this vital insight, and model it by having teachers retrieve PD insights so they stick and are applied.
• Effortful thinking – An instructional coach might give a teacher feedback on the degree to which students are in the zone of desirable difficulty – thinking hard about worthwhile tasks. “Coaching guided by evidence allows for a forensic approach to instructional design and delivery,” say Heal and Lee, “rather than an evaluative one. It invites teachers to look closer, see more, and understand the why behind their instructional decision making. When enacted with integrity, this helps teachers develop greater degrees of intention and agency in their professional growth.”
• Cognitive load – Teachers can only hold a limited amount of information in working memory, and principals should keep this in mind when deciding how many new programs a school should undertake. “Rather than offering up a steady stream of initiatives that eventually collapse under their own burden,” say Heal and Lee, “effective principals determine the weight and rate of change a school can hold… [Then] colleagues begin to feel agency and alignment where they once felt chaos and overburden.”
• Automaticity – Frequent practice builds the ability to perform a task without conscious thought, freeing up limited working memory to concentrate on higher levels of cognition. For district leaders, this cognitive principle might inform the decision to choose a math curriculum that emphasizes student mastery of basic computational skills so they have the bandwidth to learn advanced concepts.
• Prior knowledge – When some students lack the “velcro” of prerequisite knowledge and skills, they are handicapped in acquiring new material that teachers present in classrooms. “What happens if the race, culture, or lived experiences of some students don’t happen to adhere to the prior knowledge assumptions we as teachers draw upon when designing instruction?” ask Heal and Lee. “We need to ask these questions and address them so we are not leaving instructional equity to chance… When classroom instruction systematically builds new knowledge onto existing understanding, we increase the likelihood that all students will have access to the ideas they need to succeed.”
In this interview in The Learning Professional with Margaret Lee and Jim Heal, consultant/author Zaretta Hammond says that applying insights from neuroscience in schools is vital to the achievement all students, especially those who have been historically underserved. Some excerpts:
“Being anti-racist is not enough to reverse the effects of cognitive neglect,” says Hammond. “Too often, we think if we just affirm students’ cultural identities, reduce microaggressions, or make the content relevant to students’ racial and linguistic identity, they will engage and learn.” Necessary but not sufficient, she believes; two additional issues need to be addressed.
The first is what Hammond calls cognitive redshirting, a legacy of segregated schooling, with students of color receiving “a low-level, unchallenging curriculum,” filling out worksheets in ways that don’t develop their full potential, “all but guaranteeing limited social and economic mobility.”
The second is teachers going beyond a socially positive climate to foster “an intellectually safe classroom where students feel it is all right to be vulnerable, to make mistakes, and to engage in productive struggle without fear of reinforcing negative stereotypes about the intellectual capacity of certain racial and ethnic groups.”
How can intellectual rigor and psychological safety be improved for all students? Hammond believes it’s by helping teachers add some key insights from cognitive science to their cultural toolkits. Two strategies:
• Encouraging teachers to take an inquiry approach in their classrooms, constantly asking “how students respond to content, where they get confused, and how they get themselves unstuck.” This means teachers wondering “what and how students are learning and if we need to adjust our teaching as a result.” Coupling this mindset with insights from cognitive science, says Hammond, teachers can “build instructional expertise and strengthen the instructional decision-making skills that enable them to be responsive to struggling students in the moment.”
• Teachers acting as coaches of students’ cognitive development rather than focusing on discrete strategies, drawing on the full range of research-based strategies for lesson planning and execution. The goal is students becoming “metacognitive about their learning processes,” says Hammond, possessing “the skills, dispositions, and knowledge to continue expanding their learning power throughout their academic careers.”
District leaders have a crucial role in combining an equity agenda with insights from the science of learning. They need to have a firm grasp what it takes to get equitable outcomes for all students, says Hammond, act as “lead learners,” develop a shared language, eschew jargon, make implementation of new teaching practices “tangible and do-able,” and convince principals, teachers, and instructional coaches to implement change in classrooms.
Instructional coaches are “the linchpin” to change, Hammond believes, serving three complementary roles:
In her latest Coaching Letter, Isobel Stevenson (Partners for Educational Leadership) describes problems that crop up when educators take a successful program and try to scale it – replicate the idea in more schools. Drawing on research done by John List, Stevenson says that scaling is “systematically vulnerable to failure” and describes some of the ways this can happen:
• False positives – A middle-school math teacher implements the Building Thinking Classrooms model – students in randomized groups of three working standing up at erasable whiteboards tackling challenging problems. The principal is impressed by the dramatic increase in student engagement and thinking and tells other teachers to implement the model. They comply, but the improvements in the original class don’t materialize and students complain about having to work standing up.
What happened? The secret sauce in the original class was not just the whiteboards but the teacher’s careful choice of intriguing low-floor/high-ceiling tasks and the way she ramped up the challenge of tasks over time. When other teachers implemented the model, they had students doing the same textbook assignments they’d been doing at their desks, so there were no gains in engagement and level of thinking.
• Population mismatch – A coaching model that worked well for early-career teachers is implemented with veteran teachers. New teachers appreciated getting detailed feedback and suggestions from their coaches, but experienced teachers found the coaching intrusive and controlling. Conversely, a coaching model built around reflective questioning worked well with experienced teachers but left newbies frustrated; they needed more-direct guidance.
• Context dependence – A school implements weekly teacher team meetings and gets good results, leading the assistant superintendent to mandate weekly meetings in every school. These quickly degenerate into perfunctory meetings with principals in compliance mode, checking attendance and monitoring the use of protocols. Teachers feel they are being treated like students in detention and silently rebel. What was missing? Teachers in the first school were working with an instructional coach who kept the focus on instruction. Teams looked at common assessments of student learning and shared effective practices.
• Spillovers and system effects – A district adopts a strong emphasis on phonics as the key foundational skill in early reading. Teachers narrow the day-to-day curriculum to direct instruction and isolated drills because they believe that is what the district values, to the detriment of students’ broader literacy development.
In another district, leaders praise the work of one school, spotlighting it as a model site. Over time, the school is overwhelmed with visitors and giving presentations about their work, leaving educators less time to sustain the actual work.
• Cost and diseconomies of scale – A district depends on one superstar central office leader, who personally facilitates every meeting and supports every school. This approach works only as long as that one person is able to sustain it. John List quips, “You can’t scale people.”
In all of these cases, the initial success was essentially a pilot, answering the question, Can this work? But proof of concept doesn’t mean the idea will work everywhere. “To know the answer to that,” says Stevenson, “you have to keep trying things out.” She’s against the simplistic notion that you launch an idea, roll it out, and turnkey it in other schools: “You have to learn your way to scaling in education.”
In the previous Coaching Letter (#231), Stevenson distinguished between two approaches to scaling promising initiatives:
• Logic Alpha – Linear and aimed at spreading a good idea district-wide as quickly as possible, using terms like turnkey, launch, accountability, roll-out, and buy-in. The pushback might involve words like top-down, bureaucratic, cookie-cutter, flavor-of-the-month, and one-size-fits-all.
• Logic Phi – Organic, more gradual, seeking conditions where the effective practice might take root and be self-sustaining. Leaders might use words like spread, propagation, fertile ground, kindling, networks, connectors, adaptation, ownership, and positive outliers. Pushback might use words like slow, messy, unquantifiable, unpredictable – and the question, what about accountability?
Stevenson says she’s not against Logic Alpha, especially for anything involving safety – fire drills, food preparation and service, transportation, budget. “The more technical the procedure,” she says, “the easier it is to apply Logic Alpha.”
“Logic Phi requires a different set of moves,” she believes. “Rather than beginning by defining the entire plan in advance, it starts by identifying where there is already energy, curiosity, credibility, and fertile ground. It looks for positive outliers, people with ‘spark,’ and existing pockets of practice that can serve as seed crystals. It invests in helping those people deepen their understanding, connect to one another, and develop the capacity to explain, adapt, and spread the work.” Approaches in Logic Phi include (quoted directly):
- Noticing where the work is already alive;
- Cultivating small groups or teams rather than attempting organization-wide rollout;
- Creating opportunities for people to see, try, and discuss the work together;
- Helping practitioners develop a shared understanding of the underlying principles rather than a script;
- Paying close attention to relationships, trust, and informal networks;
- Connecting people who are doing similar work so they can learn from one another;
- Supporting iteration, adaptation, and local experimentation;
- Collecting ‘good enough’ data to learn what is helping or hindering spread;
- Amplifying stories, examples, and visible wins;
- Protecting the conditions that allow the work to continue;
- Being tight on the core principles and loose on everything else;
- Looking for opportunities for one person or team to ‘double’ by bringing in another;
- Watching for patterns that are emerging and strengthening them;
- And gradually shifting ownership from a small number of champions to the wider system.
Stevenson concludes: “Logic Alpha is orderly, legible, and administratively satisfying, but the approach falls apart because it produces compliance more reliably than it produces learning.”
“Many school psychologists are neurodivergent,” says Texas school psychologist Rachael Payne in this article in Communiqué. “We’re the ones who hyperfocused our way through grad school, who can see patterns in testing data that others miss, who connect deeply with the kids everyone else has given up on.” The nature of the job attracts neurodivergent people, providing variety and constant stimulation – but everyday conditions also make it challenging:
Payne can relate: she’s ADHD herself, with additional diagnoses for anxiety, depression, and others from when she was a special needs student.
U.S. corporations, she says, including Microsoft, Google, and JPMorgan Chase, have spent the last decade “figuring out how to support neurodivergent employees, not out of compassion, but because it’s profitable.” K-12 schools have focused mostly on students with learning differences, perhaps believing that for educators with those characteristics, using color-coded planners will do the trick. They haven’t for Payne; she’s tried lots of them and they’re all in “the graveyard of abandoned systems in my desk drawer.”
The problem is that planners and similar strategies are designed for neurotypical brains. “For ADHD and related conditions,” she says, “this advice fails at the fundamental level. Task initiation isn’t a motivation problem; it’s a dopamine problem. Working memory limitations mean that writing something down doesn’t guarantee you’ll remember it exists. Time blindness makes deadlines feel either infinitely far away or suddenly tomorrow.”
“The biggest lie about time management,” she continues, “is that it’s about managing time. For neurodivergent brains, it’s about managing energy, dopamine, and the neurological capacity to start the thing you need to do.” Researchers in the corporate world have figured out what works: not trying to fix neurodivergent executive functioning (working against it), but designing with and around it. Here are some of those strategies, which Payne believes can work for school psychologists [and for other educators?]:
• Block out uninterrupted time. For neurodivergent people, constant interruptions and task-switching aren’t just annoying, she says; they’re “cognitively catastrophic.” Getting back to complex work after interruptions can take 20-30 minutes, and if there are interruptions every 15 minutes, not much is going to get done. For work that requires sustained focus, Payne recommends getting support from administrators and explaining to colleagues the need for blocks of quiet time. Put up a Do Not Disturb sign, silence the phone, and close e-mail, but of course be available for a student in crisis. When Payne worked in an open-space cubicle, she taped a sign to her back: Do not talk to me. I have no self-control and a desperate need to avoid being productive.
• At the end of the day, plan how to start the next morning. Getting going with a new task is challenging, says Payne: “Sitting down to a blank screen and wondering ‘What do I do first?’ burns through executive function before you’ve accomplished anything.” She advises setting an alarm 15-20 minutes before the end of the work day, stopping whatever you’re doing, and making specific plans for what you’ll do first thing tomorrow. Open documents you’ll need and write a note on exactly where to begin (write the cognitive section of the report).
• Body double. Sitting next to someone who is also working can be very effective, says Payne. “You’re not talking (much), and you’re not collaborating; you’re just near another working human. For reasons we don’t fully understand neurologically, this helps with task initiative and sustained attention.” When working virtually, services like Focusmate pair two people, have them briefly describe what they’re working on, and they work silently on camera together.
• Use voice memos. You’re walking down a corridor and remember you’ve got to e-mail a parent about a testing issue, but when you get back to your office, the thought is gone. The solution: in the corridor, immediately pull out your phone and record a reminder. At the end of the day, play all the voice messages and transfer them to your task system. “The key is capturing the thought the moment it appears,” says Payne, “rather than trusting that you’ll remember it 30 seconds later (because you won’t).”
• E-mail as task management. Payne says that when she reads e-mails while standing in line at Starbucks, she’ll forget them minutes later – her working memory simply dumps them. She’s learned that with each e-mail, she needs to act on it, either responding right away or adding it to her task system. “Otherwise,” she says, “you’re creating invisible tasks your brain can’t track.”
• Buffer transitions. Switching from one activity (writing a report) to another (counseling a student) is harder for neurodivergent people, says Payne. It’s a good idea to schedule time between activities, not doing intense tasks back-to-back, and blocking out time at the beginning and end of the school day to transition into and out of the job’s demands.
• Use sensory regulation tools. To help deal with the emotional challenges built into the job, Payne recommends noise-cancelling headphones, a weighted lap pad, or fidget tools. Fluorescent lights are a sensory nightmare for lots of people; turn them off and use a lamp. “We recommend sensory tools for students,” she says. “You’re allowed to have them too.”
• You have permission not to be fine. “There’s enormous pressure in helping professions to be endlessly compassionate, never burned out, and always available,” says Payne. “This is unsustainable for anyone, and especially harmful for neurodivergent professionals who may already be working harder to mask and perform neurotypical professional norms. You’re allowed to have days when you’re not okay. You’re allowed to tell a trusted colleague, ‘I can’t take another crisis today, can you cover?’”
• Decide whether to disclose neurodiversity. This depends on workplace culture and norms, says Payne, and everyone has to make their own decision. Educators advocate for students to have accommodations – Disability isn’t deficit, it’s a difference – and that should apply to adults. “Whether or not you disclose a diagnosis,” she says, “you can advocate for work conditions that support executive function.” The bottom line: people are more productive when their needs are met.
“The Art of Classroom Timing: 10 Ways to Fit It All In” by Jennifer Gonzalez in Cult of Pedagogy, April 27, 2026; Gonzalez can be reached at [email protected].
© Copyright 2026 Marshall Memo LLC – AI is not used to create this publication.
You have permission to share summaries with colleagues for educational purposes, being sure to include the author/publication citation and mention that it’s a Marshall Memo summary.
About the Marshall Memo
Mission and focus:
This weekly memo is designed to keep principals, teachers, superintendents, and other educators very well-informed on current research and effective practices in K-12 education. Kim Marshall, drawing on 54 years’ experience as a teacher, principal, central office administrator, writer, and consultant lightens the load of busy educators by serving as their “designated reader.”
To produce the Marshall Memo, Kim subscribes to 60 carefully-chosen publications (see list to the right), sifts through more than a hundred articles each week, and selects 5-10 that have the greatest potential to improve teaching, leadership, and learning. He then writes a brief summary of each article, pulls out several striking quotes, provides e-links to full articles when available, and e-mails the Memo to subscribers early Tuesday (there are 50 issues a year). Every week there’s a podcast and HTML version. Artificial intelligence is not used.
Individual subscriptions are $50 for a year. Rates decline steeply for multiple readers within the same organization. See the website for these rates and how to pay by check, credit card, or purchase order.
Website:
If you go to http://www.marshallmemo.com you will find detailed information on:
• How to subscribe or renew
• A detailed rationale for the Marshall Memo
• Article selection criteria
• Publications (with a count of articles from each)
• Topics (with a count of articles from each)
• Headlines for all issues
• Reader opinions
• About Kim Marshall (including links to articles)
• A free sample issue
Subscribers have access to the Members’ Area of the website, which has:
• The current issue (in Word or PDF)
• All back issues (Word and PDF) and podcasts
• An easily searchable archive of all articles so far
• The “classic” articles from all 20 years
Core list of publications covered
Those read this week are underlined.
All Things PLC
American Educational Research Journal
American Educator
American Journal of Education
AMLE Magazine
ASCA School Counselor
ASCD SmartBrief
Cult of Pedagogy
District Management Journal
Ed Magazine
Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis
Educational Horizons
Educational Leadership
Elementary School Journal
English Journal
Exceptional Children
Harvard Business Review
Harvard Educational Review
Independent School
Journal of Adolescent and Adult Literacy
Journal of Education for Students Placed At Risk (JESPAR)
Kappa Delta Pi Record
Kappan (Phi Delta Kappan)
Knowledge Quest
Language Arts
Language Magazine
Learning for Justice (formerly Teaching Tolerance)
Literacy Today (formerly Reading Today)
Mathematics Teacher: Learning & Teaching PK-12
Middle School Journal
Peabody Journal of Education
Principal
Principal Leadership
Psychology Today
Reading Research Quarterly
Rethinking Schools
Review of Educational Research
School Administrator
School Library Journal
Social Education
Social Studies and the Young Learner
Teaching Exceptional Children
The Atlantic
The Chronicle of Higher Education
The Journal of the Learning Sciences
The Language Educator
The Learning Professional (formerly Journal of Staff Development)
The Reading Teacher
Theory Into Practice
Time
Urban Education