Marshall Memo 1114
A Weekly Round-up of Important Ideas and Research in K-12 Education
November 24, 2025
1. How much are teachers shaped by where they teach?
2. Don’t try to fix neurodivergent teachers; fix the system
3. Integrating music into high-school history classes
4. Using student talk to scaffold student writing
5. Benefits and concerns in an urban debate league
7. What is the impact of inclusion on achievement and attendance?
8. Short item: Getting parents to act on a child’s poor attendance
“There’s a gradient. The farther the phone, the more restrictive the policy, the better the outcome.”
Angela Duckworth commenting on a survey of the impact of cellphone restrictions in
U.S. public schools, quoted in “The Stricter the Cellphone Policy, the Happier the
Teacher, Research Finds” by Emily Tate Sullivan in EdSurge, October 9, 2025
“When schools intentionally support neurodivergent educators, everyone benefits. Teachers who feel safe to work in ways that fit their brains are better able to model that same acceptance for students. The classroom becomes a place where difference is understood as part of learning, not something to conceal or correct.”
Emily Kircher-Morris (see item #2)
“Autonomy is lovely, but it comes with isolation.”
Jeremy Murphy (see item #1)
“We get used to the chains we wear, and we miss them when removed.”
John Dewey (quoted in ibid.)
“Too often, students believe that success in math is about being ‘naturally good’ at it, which makes mistakes feel like evidence they don’t belong.”
Wendy Amato, quoted in “How to Make Every Student Feel Like a ‘Math Person’” by
Mary Hendrie in Education Week, November 20, 2025
“Each year and each student will teach you something new.”
Ashley Womble in “Early Career Spotlight” in Communiqué, December 2025
(Vol. 54, #4, p. 40)
“Teachers’ school contexts play critical yet underappreciated roles in their development of instructional practice in individual classrooms,” says Jeremy Murphy (College of the Holy Cross) in this article in Schools. He describes the four very different environments in which he’s taught, how students addressed him in each setting, and the ways his teaching was shaped by the very different pedagogical environments (the names of the first three schools are pseudonyms):
• Ignatius Prep – Murphy started his teaching career at a privately funded urban Jesuit-founded middle school staffed by recent college graduates who committed to a year or two of service, earned modest stipends, and lived together near the school. In 10-hour days, teachers formed close bonds with students, but the pedagogy was traditional and highly prescriptive, with a code of discipline strictly enforced by demerits, silent lunches, calls home, and meeting with the headmaster.
“Mr. Murphy” is what students called him, and he and his colleagues “occupied a profoundly different world from our students, and one too often uninterrogated,” he says. “Fixated on tucked-in shirts and eye contact – on policing the bodies of young men of color – only widened these divisions.” Desks in his classroom were in straight rows, he prioritized rules, compliance, and silence, and frequently lost his temper. Students took tests every day, and those who did poorly were punished by missing after-school activities.
In his second year at Ignatius, Murphy began to question the strict ethos he’d adopted. He stopped handing out merits and demerits, abandoned the ability-leveling system, and eased up on reading quizzes. “I increasingly tapped the relationships I had built with students to motivate them and manage classrooms,” he says. “This relational work, nurtured by the school’s focus on community, has remained central to my teaching ever since. And though my practices would never be harmonious at Ignatius, they would at least become less dissonant.”
• Promise Academy – Murphy’s next venue, an innovative grade 7-12 public school partnered with a local university, had a similar faculty and student body as Ignatius but was much less traditional. Students sat in groups, there was lots of classroom chatter, and teachers were addressed by their last name – after he had proved himself with students, he was “Murphy.” Teachers “often stood on the sidelines,” he says, “quietly keeping a pulse on students’ sensemaking. They answered questions with more questions and intervened sparingly.” Murphy quickly adopted this style of teaching, resisting “my gut instinct to weigh in and evaluate each student’s contribution… I increasingly approached teaching as a process of creating conditions for students to discover things for themselves.”
Every Wednesday morning, teachers met for two hours to share classroom strategies, confer about students, and shape school policies. Teachers visited each other’s classrooms, discussed what they noticed, and felt constantly driven to improve. “In this environment,” says Murphy, “enacting ambitious pedagogies was not difficult. It was just what you did.” Students there would not have tolerated the “pedagogy of poverty” he’d used at Ignatius. After three years at Promise Academy, he decided to try his acquired teaching skills in a tougher environment. “You sure you’re ready, Murphy?” asked a student. He thought he was.
• Highland High – At a comprehensive high school in Baltimore, students addressed him as “Mister” and he found himself wrestling with chronic absenteeism, tardiness, class cutting (first period was constantly interrupted by a stream of late students), and high teacher turnover (“How long are you gonna be here?” asked a student). Metal detectors greeted students at the front door, and “hall monitors patrolled corridors, two-way radios crackling at their hips.”
The school’s test scores were rock-bottom, to which the response was focusing on “the basics,” frequent benchmark tests, and PD about “grit” and “growth mindset.” Test scores didn’t budge, and Murphy began to see the school through the kids’ eyes – “a mirror, passively reflecting the marginalization and control students experienced beyond the schoolhouse.” Administrators popped into classrooms to see if the curriculum pacing guide was being followed, state standards were being taught, and objectives were written on the board. He and his colleagues saw these mandates “as an all-out war on teachers’ expertise.”
Murphy tried to teach the way he had at Promise Academy – studying the poetic styles of Nikki Giovanni, Audre Lorde, and Gwendolyn Brooks, writing argumentative essays on injustice, discussing The Color Purple, translating Macbeth into vernacular English – but it was an uphill battle with students. Most were so deeply ensconced in passively filling out worksheets that one pleaded with him, “Can’t we just have packets, Mister?” Murphy increasingly complied, which reduced him, as he put it, “to a foreman on a shop floor, supervising production and workflow from a clinical distance.” He remembered a John Dewey quote: We get used to the chains we wear, and we miss them when removed.
• College of the Holy Cross – In his current position as an education professor at this liberal arts college, Murphy says he enjoys “a spectacular level of autonomy, one inconceivable in my past teaching positions. This freedom has enabled me to experiment with alternatives to traditional grading systems and center relationships and community building in my practice. My administrators respect my expertise and encourage pedagogical innovation.” Students address him as “Professor Murphy,” conveying their respect for his expertise and status. “Fully actualized,” he says, “I have transcended the contextual constraints that once shadowed my practice.”
But he misses some features of Promise Academy: visiting other classrooms, discussing lessons with colleagues, a common instructional framework, a shared vision of teaching and learning. “Without such practices,” says Murphy, “the work of developing and improving one’s craft becomes a lonely, private affair. Autonomy is lovely, but it comes with isolation.” He realizes how rare and precious the collegial ethos at Promise Academy is. Too often, teachers work as independent artisans, working and learning alone, rarely talking about teaching with other professionals.
At Holy Cross, feedback comes mostly from end-of-course student surveys, and Murphy has been troubled by a common thread in these anonymous questionnaires: he should lecture more; he’s the expert; make classes less like high school. The irony is that Murphy is teaching courses that critically examine traditional K-12 practices, focusing on the difference between “doing school” and actual student learning. Lecturing about these ideas would make no sense, but that’s what some students are urging him to do.
“By emphasizing context’s role in shaping teaching,” Murphy concludes, “I do not mean to suggest that teachers in school contexts ill-structured to support ambitious instruction cannot cultivate rich learning experiences for students. I am also not suggesting that teachers in unsupportive settings can exempt themselves from pursuing ambitious pedagogies because their contexts make it inconvenient. We must not settle for less, even when forces around us make that option seem rational and expedient.
“But I am arguing that when it comes to developing and sharpening one’s craft, the overlapping contexts teachers occupy play outsized but underappreciated roles. It helps when their contexts do not work against each other. It helps when the classrooms student inhabit do not directly undermine each other. And it helps when the distance between a teacher’s and their school’s educational ideals is not perilously wide. Though it is unrealistic to think a teacher’s set of practices could be perfectly harmonious, dissonant symphonies make for bad listening all around.”
In this Cult of Pedagogy article, counselor/author Emily Kircher-Morris remembers that as a teacher, she had great difficulty with things that other teachers seemed to take in stride: doing lesson plans, remembering to send kids to their individual support classes, keeping up with her grading. “I was constantly juggling, improvising, and frantically trying to stay above water,” she says. “At the time, I didn’t realized how much my ADHD was affecting me.”
As she’s reflected on her own experience and read the research, it’s dawned on Kircher-Morris that being a teacher or school leader is really challenging for people like her. Many educators over 30 grew up at a time when ADHD was associated with hyperactive boys, autism was narrowly defined, and neurodivergent girls and high achievers were often overlooked. Adults in this age bracket are the “lost generation” of neurodivergent adults who have only recently gotten in touch with why they had so much difficulty in school.
“For many,” says Kircher-Morris, “the moment of recognition arrives with equal parts relief and disorientation.” They understand why some things about being a teacher were so taxing, but they’re still expected to be endlessly adaptable and organized, and the stigma is still there in schools where “having it together” is an expected part of being a professional. “Even today,” she says, “many teachers remain quiet about their neurodivergence, afraid it could be misinterpreted as incompetence.”
The good news is that “neurodivergent educators are often among the most creative, empathetic, and passionate educators in the building,” says Kircher-Morris. “The very traits that make us different are often what make us effective.” Several traits can strengthen a school community:
“Supporting Neurodivergent Teachers: How Schools Can Help the Helpers” by Emily Kircher-Morris in Cult of Pedagogy, November 23, 2025
In this article in Social Education, Philadelphia teacher Dave Marshall describes how he first introduced music in his history classes. As a new teacher, he occasionally played a pertinent song to start a class – for example, Edwin Starr’s “War” before a lesson on Vietnam protests. Then he began building an entire lesson around an in-depth analysis of a song – in one case, Billie Holiday’s “Strange Fruit.”
From there Marshall progressed to having students study several related songs – for example, five songs on climate change, including Joni Mitchell’s “Big Yellow Taxi” and Childish Gambino’s “Feels Like Summer.” This brought depth and passion to class discussions and students’ presentations and essays.
Marshall came up with the CALM acronym to help students analyze a song more thoughtfully:
Marshall closes with four caveats for teachers who might want to include music in a regular history course or teach an elective:
In this article in English Journal, Meghan Dougherty Kuehnle (University of Notre Dame), Amanda White (a high-school ELA teacher in Columbus, Ohio), and George Newell (Ohio State University) describe how White shifted from the formulaic five-paragraph essay and began to use student talk to stimulate and support argumentative writing. Here’s how she orchestrated that in one writing unit:
• Speed debate – In small groups, students quickly debate and reach consensus on a series of questions:
“Organizational Culture and Ethnic-Racial Socialization in a Racially Diverse Afterschool Urban Debate League” by Sebastian Castrechini in American Educational Research Journal, December 2025 (Vol. 62, #6, pp. 1207-1240); the author is at [email protected].
In this New York Times article, Jancee Dunn distinguishes between affectionate ribbing that’s light and taken well and teasing that hurts. “The harmful kind of teasing can make you feel shame and anger,” she says, “and can erode your sense of safety and trust.” Dunn asked several psychologists for their ideas on how to know when someone has crossed that line and how to shut them down. Some insights:
• People who are being teased often don’t find it as funny as the people teasing them, who tend to say they’re just kidding. If your gut tells you it’s hurtful, the other person has gone too far.
• Ask what’s behind the teasing. In one couple undergoing therapy, the husband kept teasing his wife about being late, which really annoyed her. They needed to have a conversation about this issue, rather than him disguising it as teasing.
• If you want to stop someone who’s teasing you, the best approach is being short and direct: “I’d appreciate it if you wouldn’t say things like that” or “Hey, that’s enough” or simply, “Ouch.”
• If you’re being ribbed in front of other people, it’s best to pull the teaser aside and say something like, “What’s going on here? Because it’s starting to feel like maybe you’re poking me a little. I want to give you the benefit of the doubt, because you probably don’t know that it stings.”
• If you’re a teaser, tune in to the other person’s reactions. If they’re stone-faced and silent, be quick to apologize, or say something like, “I thought we were in a place where a little lighthearted banter would be welcome, but I’m getting the sense it really wasn’t. I’m sorry.”
• How do you know if teasing is okay? If it’s kind. If it shows that they really see you and know you, which creates and sustains intimacy. In-jokes can create a warm glow between people who know and trust each other. In these circumstances, teasing is just fine.
“What To Do When a Joke Hurts Your Feelings” by Jancee Dunn in The New York Times, January 10, 2025
In this article in Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, Katharine Farham Malhotra (Teachers College, Columbia University) reports on her study of the impact of including students with disabilities in mainstream classes. She focused on a diverse, rural district in the northeastern U.S. with 17 percent of students in special education. The district succeeded in moving 90 percent of students with IEPs into general education classes for the majority of the school day.
Key findings: elementary and middle school students’ test scores and attendance were unaffected by the implementation of inclusion, and at the high-school level, ninth-grade promotion rates increased by nine percentage points and graduation rates increased by two percentage points in the years following implementation. “Findings,” concludes Malhotra, “suggest that inclusive education does not come at the expense of students’ academic progress in the short term and may improve academic outcomes in the longer term.”
Getting Parents to Act on a Child’s Poor Attendance – In this Education Week article, Cailynn Peetz Stephens reports the key findings of an analysis by School Status on how schools can connect with parents on problematic student attendance:
© Copyright 2025 Marshall Memo LLC, all rights reserved; permission is granted to clip and share individual article summaries with colleagues for educational purposes, being sure to include the author/publication citation and mention that it’s a Marshall Memo summary.
If you have feedback or suggestions, please e-mail [email protected]
About the Marshall Memo
Mission and focus:
This weekly memo is designed to keep principals, teachers, superintendents, and other educators very well-informed on current research and effective practices in K-12 education. Kim Marshall, drawing on 54 years’ experience as a teacher, principal, central office administrator, writer, and consultant lightens the load of busy educators by serving as their “designated reader.”
To produce the Marshall Memo, Kim subscribes to 60 carefully-chosen publications (see list to the right), sifts through more than a hundred articles each week, and selects 5-10 that have the greatest potential to improve teaching, leadership, and learning. He then writes a brief summary of each article, pulls out several striking quotes, provides e-links to full articles when available, and e-mails the Memo to subscribers early Tuesday (there are 50 issues a year). Every week there’s a podcast and HTML version. Artificial intelligence is not used.
Individual subscriptions are $50 for a year. Rates decline steeply for multiple readers within the same organization. See the website for these rates and how to pay by check, credit card, or purchase order.
Website:
If you go to http://www.marshallmemo.com you will find detailed information on:
• How to subscribe or renew
• A detailed rationale for the Marshall Memo
• Article selection criteria
• Publications (with a count of articles from each)
• Topics (with a count of articles from each)
• Headlines for all issues
• Reader opinions
• About Kim Marshall (including links to articles)
• A free sample issue
Subscribers have access to the Members’ Area of the website, which has:
• The current issue (in Word or PDF)
• All back issues (Word and PDF) and podcasts
• An easily searchable archive of all articles so far
• The “classic” articles from all 20 years
Core list of publications covered
Those read this week are underlined.
All Things PLC
American Educational Research Journal
American Educator
American Journal of Education
AMLE Magazine
ASCA School Counselor
ASCD SmartBrief
Cult of Pedagogy
District Management Journal
Ed Magazine
Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis
Educational Horizons
Educational Leadership
Elementary School Journal
English Journal
Exceptional Children
Harvard Business Review
Harvard Educational Review
Independent School
Journal of Adolescent and Adult Literacy
Journal of Education for Students Placed At Risk (JESPAR)
Kappa Delta Pi Record
Kappan (Phi Delta Kappan)
Knowledge Quest
Language Arts
Language Magazine
Learning for Justice (formerly Teaching Tolerance)
Literacy Today (formerly Reading Today)
Mathematics Teacher: Learning & Teaching PK-12
Middle School Journal
Peabody Journal of Education
Principal
Principal Leadership
Psychology Today
Reading Research Quarterly
Rethinking Schools
Review of Educational Research
School Administrator
School Library Journal
Social Education
Social Studies and the Young Learner
Teaching Exceptional Children
The Atlantic
The Chronicle of Higher Education
The Journal of the Learning Sciences
The Language Educator
The Learning Professional (formerly Journal of Staff Development)
The Reading Teacher
Theory Into Practice
Time
Urban Education